Answers
We're getting a construction loan for an addition to our home. The bank hired an appaiser and we're concerned. She didn't measure our house at all (and we are fairly certain what the county has from our builder is incorrect and our house is larger than what's on record); she barely glanced in rooms; I gave her a list of all the upgrades we've made and she seemed totally uninterested; she told me that things like upgraded lighting (and ours is upgraded BIG time with things like a Murano chandelier made specifically for our house in Italy that took at year to assemble and have placed in our dining room) don't count AT ALL which goes against everything I've read online about appraisels. This woman brought her grandchild who was bored and wanted to leave and the main thing she talked with us about is her wild partying lifestyle. She was some sort of groovy granny. We called our bank president and told him about what happened and he was just as shocked as we were/are. We're waiting to see what figure she MAKES UP. But, I'd like to know.....don't things like a new roof; repainting your house; upgrading all your plumbing fixtures; granite; hardwood floors and extensively upgraded lighting count at all???? It's scary that people this unprofessional are out there and in control of people's housing future. Who monitors the work they do? Can complaints be filed? I've never heard of an appraiser not even measuring your house. Very unprofessional.
I agree she was unprofessional. However, there is a difference between maintenance type improvements and actual improvements. Keep in mind, you will never get dollar for dollar of what you spent. It doesn't work that way. First what you have to consider is what the other similar homes in your area sold for and what amenities they had like yours. For example if the home next door sold and had exactly the same improvements, then your improvements wouldn't be as valuable. If you had granite and the sold's had laminate, your's is worth more. If all comparable have hardwood floors, then you have an improvement, but it's expected in that level of sale. See what I mean.
Is anyone watching us, you betcha! Each appraisal goes through a review process by the lender. These lenders have hired appraisers with less than 5 years experience to review our work, which results in unnecessary revisions, additional comparables, listings for cryn' out loud, that do not add credibility to the report. They just want to maktheirer employers think they are doing a lot of work. The lenders are the ones that caused this whole economic mess, yet the appraiser is being crucifieded. Also, keep in mind that the appraiser is suppose to be a unbiased, and an objective third party. Neither the lender nor the homeowner is suppose to influence them in any manner.
I understand your concern, but wait and see. By law you are suppose to be given a copy three days before closing. Read the report carefully. If you think she missed something, then I would go back to the bank CEO and ask for them to have it corrected and/or another appraisal done.
It's highly recommended to watch in high quality - that's the format I saved it as. Low quality is blurry. My method of using a graahk. I ...
Bank of Granite faces serious federal sanctions ...
Regulators have placed Bank of Granite under a so-called “cease-and-desist” order, the most serious sanction so far against the troubled Granite Falls-based bank.
It's a vast change of fortune for a community bank once praised by Warren Buffett as one of the best-run banks in the country. But in the past two years, it has lost tens of millions of dollars, suspended its shareholder payout and scaled back on lending.
The cease-and-desist order, which the bank announced Friday afternoon, does not mean the bank is going to fail. But it signals that regulators are seriously concerned and want it to stop practices they deem unsafe. The order imposes restrictions requiring the bank to raise capital levels and assess its leaders, among other steps.
...News
Bank of Granite Corporation Announces NASDAQ Compliance and Preliminary Fourth ...CNNMoney.com (press release) - Feb 04, 2010
Charlotte Business Journal (blog)Bank of Granite Corporation is the parent company of Bank of Granite and Granite Mortgage. Bank of Granite operates twenty full-service banking offices in Increase in Bank of Granite share price eases pressureall 12 news articles »
Dallas Morning News - Feb 21, 2010
Beal Bank owner - Dallas' richest man - paved his own road to richesHe acquired a failed Alabama bank in December from the Federal Deposit Insurance Corp. and picked up another in New Mexico last month. His overall banking and more »istockAnalyst.com (press release) - Feb 23, 2010
Beal Bank owner paved his own road to becoming Dallas' richest manHe acquired a failed Alabama bank in December from the Federal Deposit Insurance Corp. and picked up another in New Mexico last month. His overall banking and more »MarketWatch (press release) - Feb 17, 2010
HomeStreet Bank Announces New CEO, CFO: Mark K. Mason Named Chairman & CEO In 1986, Continental entered the thrift and banking market with the creation of Continental Savings Bank in Seattle. -- In 1988, the company's income and more »istockAnalyst.com (press release) - Feb 24, 2010
"Our outlook for the banking industry is pretty consistent with our outlook for the economy in general for this year, and that is that we're likely to just and more »The Street Sweeper - Feb 24, 2010
According to the SEC, Schreiber and fellow Granite broker David Baker financed generous gifts – including expensive trips, home rentals and car services and more »NumisMaster.com - Feb 24, 2010
Readers may address questions or comments about this article or National Bank Notes in general to Mark Hotz directly by e-mail at markbhotz@aol.com.